The new user interface is in preview!

Want to check it out? Click here! (If you don't like it, you can still switch back)

The draft is underway!

Click here to go to your war room, or visit the war room item in the draft menu.

League Forums

Main - Suggestion Box

Re: Trade Solution

By jnormaniv
4/05/2016 4:41 pm
Each league needs 1-3 appointed commissioners that approve or don't approve trades and all transactions. That will be the only thing that will fix all these problems.

MORE FISHY STUFF going on in CUST-10 I've about had enough. Glad I didn't spend $20 for credits.
Last edited at 4/05/2016 4:41 pm

Re: Trade Solution

By jnormaniv
4/05/2016 6:15 pm
Also need to make it so you can't cut a player drafted in the first 4 rounds to avoid things like this from happening.

Re: Trade Solution

By punisher
4/05/2016 8:52 pm
jnormaniv wrote:
Each league needs 1-3 appointed commissioners that approve or don't approve trades and all transactions. That will be the only thing that will fix all these problems.

MORE FISHY STUFF going on in CUST-10 I've about had enough. Glad I didn't spend $20 for credits.


yeah like that is going to work.

like people are going to prove or deny trades especially when it comes to their own teams , to their division rivals , to their conference rivals , to their league rivals , etc. because really people here probably cant be partial to trades .

only suggestion that will work is just leave the league and find a league that is more your speed where they don't do anything that you think is FISHY and problem solved.

whatever you do GOOD LUCK.

Re: Trade Solution

By martinwarnett
4/06/2016 6:18 am
Well, talking about CUST-10;

you signed a LB, Jeremy Lane in FA3, 2020. Changed him from MLB to WLB in FA4, 2020. Injured in pre-season game 1, switched back to MLB almost immediately and then traded - as transactions tab for league shows no player going to you, presumably you got a draft pick.

Some would think it suspicious a player was picked up and traded so soo. Others would think it's a part of the game.

So you tell me, who would decide who these commissioners are - you? The same person who falsely claimed the bidder who won a released FA was a cheat? Who would train those commissioners to accurately determine who a cheat was?

How would you prevent said commissioners colluding to block legit trades - what oversight and accountability would there be?

On a different online game in a different genre, I worked catching cheats as part of the game, officially. Let me put it simply; there were plenty of slackers on that regard - I nailed cheats left right and centre. Others didn't, to the extent that cheaters were in that official group and indeed entire nations prospered as a result.

It's right for the community to question things. It's never right for the community to act as judge jury and executioner - especially when they make false cheat claims.

=========

As for no cut... I presume you've played the game long enough to know AI picks in particular can be somewhat bizarre.

Under your view, say AI drafted a punter for you in round 2; going to be naff all trade value, you've already got a passable punter then whoopee-doo. According to you, you have to keep two punters on the roster or cut the existing one...
Last edited at 4/06/2016 6:29 am

Re: Trade Solution

By TAFIV
4/06/2016 8:17 am
martinwarnett wrote:

As for no cut... I presume you've played the game long enough to know AI picks in particular can be somewhat bizarre.

Under your view, say AI drafted a punter for you in round 2; going to be naff all trade value, you've already got a passable punter then whoopee-doo. According to you, you have to keep two punters on the roster or cut the existing one...


+1

not only that but what if you have a pretty solid team overall and are trying to get star players for starters......and jnormaniv said no cuts on 4th round and up picks, as an example in mfn-19 our draft for the current season had high 50s to low 60s for 4th round say your player tanks horribly he could drop all the way down to high 40s to low 50s and now i'm stuck having to keep a completely useless player on my team just because he was a 4th round pick????? that's ridiculous

Re: Trade Solution

By Tanman721
4/09/2016 3:55 am
-1